“Steering Our Own Ship?” An Assessment of Self-Determination and Self-Governance for Community Development in Nunavut


  • Roger Ritsema
  • Jackie Dawson University of Ottawa
  • Miriam Jorgensen University of Arizona
  • Brenda Macdougall University of Ottawa




The Northern Review 41 (2015): 157–180

Climate change, the global demand for energy, and the depletion of easily accessible natural resources has led to an increase in mining activities in the Arctic, including in Nunavut, a region rich in resources but remote in comparison to the rest of Canada. Nunavut is a predominantly Inuit socio-political region created in 1999 via the Nunavut Act and the Nunavut Land Claims Agreement (NLCA) (1993). The NLCA also enshrined the Inuit right to manage the region’s minerals and other natural resources. Yet, despite this power to “steer their own ship,” Inuit communities struggle to maximize the benefits from resource development. Pond Inlet is a coastal hamlet on Baffin Island close to the newly operational Mary River Iron Ore Mine, an open pit mine with the potential to bring significant economic opportunities to the region. Using a framework developed by the Harvard Project on American Indian Economic Development, a case study of Pond Inlet highlights factors that contribute to and hinder Arctic Aboriginal communities’ successful local development. A total of 47 semi-structured interviews were conducted with key informants in Pond Inlet and the territory’s capital, Iqaluit. Findings underscore the importance of Indigenous community self-determination, effective and culturally relevant governing institutions, and clear visioning for the future. In Pond Inlet, key barriers to maximizing local benefits relate to institutional and governance challenges. Evidence from this study suggests that Pond Inlet will better succeed with local community development by strengthening its governance mechanisms to support the goals of self-determination.

Author Biographies

Roger Ritsema

MA, Geography, University of Ottawa, 2014

Jackie Dawson, University of Ottawa

Canada Research Chair in Environment, Society, and
Policy; Associate Professor, Geography

Miriam Jorgensen, University of Arizona

Research Professor, Udall Center for Studies in
Public Policy; Research Director, Native Nations Institute;  Research Director, Harvard Project on American Indian Economic Development; Pofessorial Fellow, Melbourne School of Government, University of Melbourne

Brenda Macdougall, University of Ottawa

Chair, Métis Research; Associate Professor, Geography






Resources and Sustainable Development in the Arctic

Most read articles by the same author(s)